Social Business CollaborationBusiness social networks may appeal to the tech-romantics amongst us (doesn’t take much to make us shout “paradigm shift!”) but they evoke divergent emotions in actual users.

Some say “Pfffft!”. “The productivity panacea” others say (read HBR's six business attitudes leaders take towards social media). Now if you follow experts and the tech-media, you would think the latter are forward thinking visionaries, while the former are change-resistant and reality denying (and stuffy). But is that more than a subconscious bias in the tech expert world?

Business social networks, or some of the design principles (activity walls, profiles, social messaging), are definitely here to stay. At a very practical level, they are simply vastly more efficient than email for managing internal interactions -- less clutter (no spammers, scammers, sales pitches, solicitations), more open (emails can be seen only by the participants), and more efficient (a single conversation thread as opposed to multiple emails for every discussion). For that simple reason, corporate social networks will find their way into most organizations at some level, as is already in evidence; 67% of companies adopted business social networks in 2012 according to the IDC.

Collaboration Style Social Business

No One Size Fits All for Collaboration

However, the claims are a lot grander than just that -- enterprise social tools will invert the decision making processes, spur innovation, make for flatter and more democratic companies, finally solve the problem of knowledge management and make for more satisfied employees.

Does it necessarily hold true for organizations of all sizes and types? The “contingency theory” of management, based on 100 years of organizational experience tells us that there is no “one right way.” In my work I see that there are as many views of “collaboration” as there are companies -- some companies are simply content with email, some approach collaboration as a project management problem, others want an online repository of documents, and still others want to display information in context using intranet pages. Some actively seek enterprise social networks and see the value, but others will hear none of it.

Those who are not convinced would give the following argument:

Workers perform the best when you create context in terms of clear ideas of what is expected of them, who they are answerable to, how they are expected to complete their tasks -- clearly defined objectives, responsibilities, and processes. Undirected social conversations just end up in meaningless chatter.”