Next year will be the year gamification fails. It’s a concept built on hype, and 80 percent of all programs will die by 2014, according to Gartner.
Rajat Paharia disagrees — 100 percent. The founder of Bunchball, a provider of online gamification solutions, he thinks it is only logical, in a data-driven world, that organizations implement gamification strategies to motivate employees and customers, and recognize, reward and encourage a deeper learning of concepts for better business outcomes.
Which side of the gamification hemisphere are you on? Is it a fad or here to stay? We caught up this week with a few industry insiders to find out what they had to say.
What is it Anyway?
Paharia told us the first misconception in the business world is the definition of gamification. His suggestion: Forget the "game" part and focus on the concept itself, which uses real data and game mechanics to encourage participation through rewards.
Rob Howard, chief technology officer of Zimbra, a messaging and collaboration solution provider, tells us “gamification is simply a mechanism to encourage more participation, much like a points-based rewards system for travelers offered by an airline."
However, Howard added, “organizations should consider implementing gamification tactics only when they have a clear understanding of the purpose of their community. For example, using gamification in a support community provides recognition to contributors and increases the motivation to contribute.”
Steve Sims, VP of solutions & design at Badgeville, a gamification platform provider, said gamification takes the principles that motivate behavior that are found in gaming and applies them to non-game experiences in organizations.
He cited his company's efforts with American Express, which uses its behavior platform to increase travel compliance across its customer base's employees. EMC uses gamification to increase engagement across their customer community. Organizations like Deloitte and Accenture are focused on increasing the efficiency of training programs across their global workforce.
Jed Cawthorne, who works at a major North American financial institution as a senior manager of intranet initiatives, wrote earlier this year that he simply does not get the concept of gamification.
It’s heading into “overblown” and “trendy fad” territory, he said, echoing the Gartner perspective.
“I guess my problem,” Cawthorne wrote, “is that while I can understand the theoretical benefits of gamification to salespeople by adding features to their CRM or other specific scenarios, I just don't see benefits in the wholesale adoption of gamification to the Intranet, collaboration and Information Management spaces.”
Catching up with Cawthorne this week, we asked him if there is one compelling reason, he sees, to not implement gaming into organizations?
“Yes,” he told us, “potentially many — mostly based on the organization’s culture. Is there a cultural fit? If not, what is the change management cost required in order to gain the benefits?”
To date, Cawthorne added, he has not seen a compelling "one size fits all" reason that makes it a “killer app” for all organizations — or even all parts of one single organization. He warns that a poorly crafted gamification is one not geared toward its particular audience, suffering from being too generic.
“Consequences include poor adoption or outright rebellion,” he said.
For many organizations, the concept could simply fail as a cultural fit. There could exist, Cawthorne said, a “lack of integrated thinking” and an “inability to embed in a fully end to end set of HR and business processes."
"If this is the case," he said, "gamification would not be a meaningful experience."
More participation, the merrier. That’s part of the belief behind using gamification, according to its supporters.
“A successful use of rewards and recognition through game theory leads to an increase in participation,” Howard said. “The more active a community is, the more unique content is created and the more valued the community becomes.”
And, to boot, organizations get invaluable insight into its customer base through such measures, and therefore can identify experts, he added.
Businesses should not decide whether or not to implement gamification within their organization but rather analyze a particular use case for gamification, Sims added.
“The compelling reason is to drive better business and organizational outcomes through increased engagement and productivity in your workforce through a win-win scenario where users benefit as well,” Sims said;
- Will BlackBerry Once Again be King of Mobility?
- The SharePoint Information Governance Problem
- 3 Ways Social Media is Changing Online Content
- Adobe: IBM's Silverpop Deal Could Trigger 'Nightmare'
- It's Official: Forrester Says Campaign Marketing Is Dead
- Turn Off the Phones and Leave the Customers Alone
- Why Box's Bad Financials Might Be Right on the Money