Content Here Releases Report on Open Source Java WCMs
![]()
Content Here, an analyst and consulting firm that focuses on content management technologies has published a report entitled Open Source Web Content Management in Java.
The report provides detailed reviews of seven software solutions including Alfresco, Apache Lenya, Daisy CMS, Hippo CMS, Jahia, Magnolia, and OpenCms. In addition, the report discusses the web content management marketplace in general and how open source solutions fit into this market.
This report is great because it provides companies with a review of open source solutions similar to the reports provided by CMS Watch, Gartner and Forrester on proprietary content management solutions.
But according to it’s author, Seth Gottlieb, you won’t see any Magic Quadrant or winning solution in this review. “There is no universally superior product. Each has its strengths and weaknesses”
The 160 page report reviews seven solutions found in two categories: Informational Brochure Sites (Magnolia, OpenCms, Apache Lenya, Daisy) and Web Content Management Platform (Alfresco, Hippo, Jahia).
|
SPONSORSHIP |
Not all products in the report qualify under the Open Source Definition, but have approached other business models for free software.
To complete his review, Gottlieb did a number of things:
- Subscribed to project mailing lists, monitoring the volume and nature of activity
- Talked to users of the software
- Built Prototypes that were reviewed by a project committer or company officer
In his evaluation he describes the architecture and integration, usability factors, content contribution and presentation, and how the community and project itself is trending.
The Open Source Web Content Management in Java report also includes the following information:
- Strategies for evaluating different types of open source projects
- How to consider open source in conjunction with commercial options
- Insights into the project communities, their histories and their outlooks
- A rating system for comparing/contrasting the open source WCM options
“Companies considering open source software greatly benefit from a comprehensive understanding of an open source project — its origins, differentiators, strengths, and weaknesses,” said Content Here’s principal and founder Seth Gottlieb. “Our goal is to provide a go-to resource for those seeking a contextual overview of the market and/or a detailed look at some leading projects. Just like with commercial web content management software, knowledge of the platform, realistic expectations, scope control and adherence to process are all key factors in successful open source product implementations,” said Gottlieb.
You can read an excerpt of the report which includes the Table of Contents and Introduction to the report, or you can go buy it straight away.
Read more breaking news:
- Employees Provided a Cubeless Web 2.0 Community
- PaperThin Reports Growth, Talks About Future
- Interact with Your Socialcast Community Using iPhone, Gmail
- Ektron Makes a Move to the West
- Open Text Maps Out the Future for eDOCS
- Shoutlet Makes Social Media Easy
- When Technology Fails, Behaviors Get Analyzed
- A Drupal Web CMS Webinar: Everything You Need to Know
- Sitecore Web CMS Recommended to SMBs
- Adobe Max 2008 Winners Announced
Comments
Well, I'm not sure how many open source efforts are really altruistic in nature. Is this a reasonable standard to hold people to? I would say not.
Just look at Sun buying MySQL, or conversely MySQL selling to Sun. Red Hat makes loads of money. Alfresco and Nuxeo are certainly not in the business of altruism. And the founder of the Drupal project, Dries Buytaert, has just started a for profit company, Acquia, as a vehicle to make money from Drupal-based efforts.
Damn them all? Hmm...seems hard to swallow.
I don't mean to be cynical here, but let's be realistic, most people have got a bit of a financial agenda in mind, regardless of whether or not they are working with open source projects. At the end of the day, there are bills to pay.
What Seth Gottlieb has done provides a valuable informational resource to an industry starved for reliable analysis. Speaking from first hand knowledge, producing such a report is no small task. Of course it shouldn't be free.
Posted by: Brice Dunwoodie on February 15, 2008 11:11 AMAdd a Comment
Get a New Job!
(View All
|
Feed
| Post a Job)
- Lead UI/User Experience Designer at edufire
- Senior Web Developer at Trapeze
- ActionScript Engineer (ActionScript Assassin) at Meebo
- Software Chameleon at BorderStylo
- Web UI Developer at GETCO
- Copywriter at Navajo Company Inc.
- Principal Technical Architect at TandemSEVEN
- EMC/Documentum content management Architect at Urpan Technologies, Inc.


Newsletter:
Email a Friend
Digg It


How wonderfully ironic that this report on open source CMSs should be a paid report.
How very altruistic of them!
angus
Posted by: Angus on February 15, 2008 10:38 AM