Gartner's Magic Quadrant For Horizontal Portals: Oracle, IBM, Microsoft, SAP, Liferay Top Dogs

4 minute read
Josette Rigsby avatar

Gartner has released its latest magic quadrant (MQ) for horizontalportals. The market continues to evolve as platforms gain new features thatincreasingly blur the boundaries between the portal market and other sectorslike content and experience management. Theportal market may be changing, but Gartner’s vendor categorizations are verysimilar to last year’s incarnation of the report.

What Exactly Is a Horizontal Portal

Gartner defines a portal as

a Web software infrastructure that provides interaction with relevant information assets (for example, information/content, applications and business processes), knowledge assets and human assets by select targeted audiences, delivered in a highly personalized manner."


In layman’s terms, it means that portals are platforms that organizations can use to develop their own specific portal implementations.

As in other industries, trends like mobile, social, cloud and user experience management, are having a major impact. Vendors are adding new features and the line between portals and other types of platforms are blurring. Some vendors are using the evolution and opportunity to move away from the portal label and reinvent themselves in an attempt to disassociate themselves with the somewhat mixed history of the portal market -- project death marches, products that never live up to expectations and lackluster user adoption.

Gartner’s Vendor Ranking

This year, Gartner dropped Tibco from its MQ and added Adobe, eXo and United Planet, which resulted in an evaluation of sixteen vendors as compared to last year’s fourteen. There were no changes in Gartner’s vendor inclusion/exclusion criteria. As in 2011, the firm only evaluated vendors for the magic quadrant that had:

Learning Opportunities

  • A container or framework and component model
  • Security administration
  • The ability to integrate with a wide range of technologies
  • Personalization
  • Content management
  • Business process management (BPM) and a mechanism for providing or integrating with workflow and BPM tools or platforms
  • Support for multichannel and multi-device delivery
  • Sales and support in at least two geographic regions (North America; Latin America; Europe, the Middle East and Africa; Japan; and Asia/Pacific)
  • Clients in more than one industry vertical
  • US$ 4 million in portal-related revenue and at least 100 enterprise customers

Gartner evaluated the selected vendors based on their ability to execute and completeness of vision.

The Leaders

The leader’s quadrant is identical to previous rankings. Gartner still considers Microsoft SharePoint, IBM WebSphere PortalOracle WebCenter, SAP NetWeaver and Liferay market leaders that “have a full range of capabilities to support a variety of portal deployment scenarios, and have demonstrated consistent product delivery in meeting customer needs for a substantial period of time.” However, the leaders aren’t perfect. Gartner cautions that:

  • SharePoint 2013 design principles appear to be significantly different, with Web Parts shifting toward tile-based apps that support an off-box execution model that may be difficult for organizations to adapt to. Also, according to Gartner, the cloud-based version of SharePoint may not be a suitable platform for horizontal portals in the enterprise because of its limited support for multiple and external sites as will the challenges integrating the platform with other solutions.
  • Liferay is still struggling to gain the expertise to understand and solve enterprise scale business problems.
  • SAP Netweaver is still has problems with usability and flexibility and SAP architectural approach can result in vendor lock-in if organizations don’t exercise caution in implementation.

The Challengers, Visionaries and Niche Players

The challengers’ quadrant remained sparsely populated. Last year, Red Hat’s JBoss was the only platform Garter considered a challenger. This year Red Hat shares its piece of the MQ with OpenText, which Gartner considered a visionary in 2011, but ranked in the challengers’ quadrant in 2010. Following the theme of the rest of the report, the visionary quadrant changed very little.  Covisint (Compuware), salesforce.com and Backbase returned joined by newcomer Adobe, Drupal, edge IPK, eXo, United Planet and DotNetNuke populated the final niche player’s quadrant.

Marketers almost always relish their appearance on Gartner’s list. However, organizations should not be quite so excited. A MQ isn’t a substitute for a RFP process. Do you agree with Gartner’s ranking this year? Is the portal label becoming obsolete given the recent changes in the market? We would love to hear your thoughts.

About CMSWire

For nearly two decades CMSWire, produced by Simpler Media Group, has been the world's leading community of customer experience professionals.


Today the CMSWire community consists of over 5 million influential customer experience, digital experience and customer service leaders, the majority of whom are based in North America and employed by medium to large organizations. Our sister community, Reworked gathers the world's leading employee experience and digital workplace professionals.

Join the Community

Get the CMSWire Mobile App

Download App Store
Download google play