Editorial
The Gist
-
Vague goals fail. Undefined customer success goals lead to wasted resources, poor alignment and missed opportunities for measurable growth.
-
Reverse-engineer success. Reverse-engineering customer success by analyzing what already works allows for clearer, more impactful goals and strategies.
-
Focus on metrics. Shift focus to actionable, outcome-driven metrics that connect directly to customer and business outcomes to guarantee real value.
Many customer success goals fail because they’re built to sound impressive, not to deliver results. Vague promises like “increase retention” or “improve satisfaction” dominate strategy meetings, yet these kinds of statements often lack clarity, measurability and alignment with what actually matters to customers and their business. If goals aren’t specific, measurable and directly tied to economic value, they aren’t goals; they’re guesses.
For marketing leaders tasked with driving customer success, hazy goals waste time, money, resources and focus. They leave teams spinning their wheels and chasing outcomes that are neither actionable nor meaningful.
Worse yet, they miss opportunities to create real value for customers and the business. A Gartner survey revealed that only 48% of digital transformation initiatives meet or exceed expected business outcomes, often due to undefined or misaligned goals.
Table of Contents
- Why Undefined Customer Success Goals Lead to Failure
- Reverse-Engineering Customer Success for Measurable Results
- A Framework for Digital Leaders
- How to Measure the Right Customer Success Metrics
- Identifying and Correcting Misaligned Goals
- Designing Goals That Drive Success
- Core Questions Around Customer Success Goals
Why Undefined Customer Success Goals Lead to Failure
Vague Goals Drain Resources
Unclear goals like “drive loyalty” or “increase retention” lack specificity and leave teams going in circles on initiatives that look promising but fail to deliver real value. For example, a customer loyalty program might attract sign-ups but see little engagement because it focuses on acquisition rather than what actually sustains loyalty, like meaningful rewards or seamless redemption.
This lack of clarity wastes time and energy and traffic, and it misdirects effort toward surface-level wins instead of what truly drives retention or meaningful growth.
Conflicting Priorities Disrupt Customer Success
When goals are poorly defined, teams often interpret them in conflicting ways. Marketing might focus on churn metrics, operations on response times and sales on acquisitions. These are all worthwhile efforts, but without coordination, they pull in different directions. These silos fragment the customer experience and erode trust. Disjointed efforts weaken customer relationships and undermine loyalty, which prevents teams from delivering cohesive experiences.
Missed Opportunities Hinder Growth
Fragmented efforts come at a steep cost. Resources spent on low-impact activities are resources not spent on initiatives that actually could drive measurable results. The most successful companies don’t optimize isolated touchpoints; they think big picture and reverse-engineer their success. Instead of chasing disconnected KPIs, they design strategies around the full customer journey. McKinsey research shows that organizations taking this approach have seen.
Without cohesive goals, teams risk wasting effort on work that feels productive but fails to drive real outcomes. If there is no direct path to impact, it’s just noise.
Related Article: How to Balance Risk, Stability and Customer Success
Reverse-Engineering Customer Success for Measurable Results
Start with the outcome you want, then work backward. Instead of starting with what you hope to achieve, begin with what’s already working. Reverse-engineering success makes sure your goals are grounded in reality, not just aspiration.
Start With What Works
Success leaves clues. Instead of guessing at what might drive better outcomes, trace backward from your most successful customers. What behaviors, touchpoints and experiences consistently drive their loyalty? By identifying these patterns, you can design outcomes that replicate their success.
For example, let’s say a SaaS company dug into the data and found that customers who engaged with onboarding tutorials within their first week were twice as likely to renew their subscriptions. Instead of guessing at what might improve retention, the company could prioritize optimizing and promoting those tutorials, which would likely drive measurable results.
Why Reverse-Engineering Works
Reverse-engineering takes the guesswork out of goal setting. By starting with what customers already value, you can focus on initiatives with proven ROI, build strategies around real and established customer behaviors, and avoid wasting time on assumptions or untested ideas.
The best strategies don’t start from scratch; they start by recognizing patterns.
"Successful entrepreneurs also excel at something else: pattern recognition. They possess an extraordinary capacity for identifying profitable opportunities by linking successes they’ve observed in the past with changes now taking place in the market."
- Ron Friedman, Decoding Greatness
Marketing and customer success teams can apply this same mindset by identifying the behaviors that already drive retention and growth, then scaling and adapting them for even greater impact.
A Framework for Digital Leaders
Before starting the journey, know what’s on the test. To make sure customer success goals are actionable, they must be defined from three perspectives.
The Customer View
What tangible outcomes do customers need to achieve their outcomes?
Examples: Faster reward redemption in a loyalty program, seamless onboarding and access to real-time support.
The Business View
How does success tie directly to measurable growth?
Examples: Reducing churn in the first 90 days by 15% improves customer retention, and it also translates into millions in retained revenue. This kind of measurable economic success can justify further investments, making each improvement effectively pay for itself.
The Team View
What can each team directly control to achieve success? This might include goals like these.
-
Customer service team: Improve response times by 25%.
-
Product team: Streamline onboarding to reduce time-to-value.
-
Marketing team: Personalize outreach campaigns to re-engage dormant customers.
When each initiative leads to a clear, measurable outcome, teams can focus on what matters most. Not every initiative has to work perfectly; what’s important is that the portfolio of efforts, as a whole, moves the needle on progress and ROI.
How to Measure the Right Customer Success Metrics
Focus on Outcome-Driven Metrics
Metrics like time to first value (TTFV) — how long it takes a customer to achieve their first meaningful success — are more actionable than engagement or awareness-based numbers. TTFV provides a clear indication of whether customers are experiencing early wins, which allows you to adjust your strategy if progress stalls. Similarly, monitoring return rates can reveal how effectively your customer experience initiatives are building loyalty and repeat business.
Webinar
Sep
25
CMS Briefing: A Live Look at What’s Next in AI-Driven Platforms
Learn how leading organizations are using AI‑driven tools to publish faster, personalize smarter and stay secure.
Register
Webinar
Sep
25
Call Spoofing Trends Financial Institutions Can't Afford to Ignore
Don't let robocalls sabotage your customer relationships. Learn how to secure your voice channel.
Register
Webinar
Oct
15
Agentic AI Playbook Real-World Customer Service Use Cases You Can Deploy Now
Boost self-service by 30% and slash call volume by 63% with agentic AI.
Register
Webinar
On demand
Ready or Not: How Data-First Organizations Are Unlocking Agentforce Potential
Learn how to cut through the noise, activate Agentforce and build a Salesforce AI strategy that actually delivers.
Watch Now
Webinar
On demand
CX Reality Check: What Your Customers Are Really Thinking
Register now and get the insights you need to not just meet rising expectations, but exceed them.
Watch Now
Webinar
On demand
Content Leaders Collective: What a Good CCMS Actually Looks Like
Discover how content leaders transform clunky systems into growth engines — and why your competitors are ahead.
Watch Now
Eliminate Vanity Metrics
While metrics like page views or social media likes can look impressive, they don’t always translate into meaningful outcomes. Even widely used KPIs like net promoter score (NPS) may not provide direct insight into measurable business growth or customer success unless paired with more actionable data. Instead, focus on metrics that directly connect to customer and business outcomes, such as retention rates, repeat purchases or churn reduction.
Iterate Constantly
Metrics aren’t static. As customer needs and business priorities evolve, so should your metrics. Regularly review your goals and adjust your KPIs to make sure they remain aligned with what drives value. Even with the right metrics in place, progress can stall. That’s why recognizing early warning signs and knowing how to correct a goal before it derails is just as critical as setting the goal in the first place.
Related Article: The Real Metrics of a Customer Success Culture
Identifying and Correcting Misaligned Goals
Warning Signs of Failure
-
Progress stalls despite increased effort.
-
While there’s improvement in some areas, you fail to deliver the desired outcomes overall.
-
Teams struggle to see how their work connects to the broader goal, especially when different departments have conflicting priorities or varied outlooks on success.
-
Customers report satisfaction but ultimately disengage shortly after.
How to Course Correct
When goals fail, it’s often because they’ve lost alignment with customer needs or business objectives. To course correct, you should reassess whether the goal still reflects what matters most to your customers. Also, identify bottlenecks or friction points slowing progress. Finally, refine your strategy to realign with the original outcome.
Designing Goals That Drive Success
Great customer success outcomes aren’t dreamed up in siloed strategy meetings. They’re built in collaborative sessions where teams can identify what customers value most and design a measurable journey backward from there. Rather than relying on a single plan, develop a living framework that allows for adjustment as customer needs and business conditions change.
“Companies that succeed in aligning customer experience with business outcomes can generate sustained revenue growth, cost savings, and customer loyalty.”
- McKinsey
For marketing leaders and strategic decision-makers, defining success in clear, actionable terms improves the customer experience and transforms goals into measurable economic results.
Core Questions Around Customer Success Goals
Editor's note: Here are two important questions to ask about customer success:
Why do undefined customer success goals fail?
They fail because they are vague, lack clarity and are not tied to measurable outcomes. Without specificity, teams waste resources on ineffective initiatives, and they misalign efforts and hinder progress.
How can marketing leaders create actionable goals?
Marketing leaders can create actionable goals by reverse-engineering success. This involves identifying successful customer behaviors and experiences, and then designing goals based on these patterns to drive measurable outcomes and alignment across teams.
Learn how you can join our contributor community.
