Feature
The Gist
- Privacy revolution. Google's phase-out of third-party cookies in Chrome, driven by privacy concerns, marks a pivotal change in digital advertising and consumer data privacy.
- Strategy shift. Advertisers and marketers must pivot to first-party data strategies, enhancing direct customer relationships and consent-based data collection.
- Innovative adaptation. The industry is urged to adopt new ad technologies, like Google's Privacy Sandbox, and explore fresh marketing avenues, such as DOOH and Connected TV.
As Google officially begins the gradual deprecation of third-party cookies in Chrome — starting this month with a select user base — the digital marketing landscape stands on the cusp of a transformation. With the full phase-out expected to reshape the industry by the end of the third quarter, marketers and advertisers are at a critical juncture. The move, intended to bolster user privacy, signals an imperative shift toward robust first-party data strategies and innovative ad technologies. This article aims to examine the unfolding implications of this cookie-less future and the proactive steps being taken by the marketing and advertising community to embrace the new norms of internet privacy.
Introduction to Google’s Phased Elimination of Third-Party Cookies
Google's phased elimination of third-party cookies, starting January 2024 with a small percentage of Chrome users, signals a major change for marketers and advertisers. This initiative, which was driven by privacy concerns and regulatory pressures, aims to end third-party cookie tracking entirely by the third quarter of 2024.
For marketers and advertisers, the disappearance of third-party cookies requires a shift in digital advertising strategies, particularly in programmatic advertising. The immediate impact, while initially affecting only 1% of Chrome users, will eventually challenge campaign reach and frequency, conversion volume, and targeting accuracy as the ability to track users across sites diminishes.
In response, Google has developed what it calls the Privacy Sandbox, offering anonymized signals instead of cookies for ad performance metrics and user attribution. This solution encourages advertisers to rely on APIs for aggregated data and to integrate directly with Google's advertising platforms for a smoother transition to a cookie-less environment.
Marketers are being advised to bolster first-party data strategies, adopt new measurement methods such as causal proof studies, and explore new marketing opportunities such as Digital Out Of Home (DOOH) and Connected TV that don't depend on cookies. These methods can help maintain and even expand marketing reach in innovative ways.
The advice for the near term is clear: Websites and publishers should actively test and measure the impact of cookie deprecation, implementing necessary fixes and alternatives. Advertisers are urged to refine first-party data collection and activation strategies, while analysts and marketers should collaborate on new measurement tools and consider alternative advertising avenues like DOOH and Connected TV.
Related Article: Contextual Targeting vs. Cookies: Who Will Win in 2024?
The Impact on Consumer Data Privacy
The removal of third-party cookies marks a significant advancement in consumer data privacy, as it curtails the widespread and often cringe tracking of user behavior across the internet. This change empowers consumers with greater control over their personal data, reducing unsolicited tracking and enhancing privacy. For consumers, this shift means a reduction in the volume of personalized and targeted ads derived from extensive tracking, and signifies a notable step toward a digital environment where consumer privacy is prioritized and the balance between personalized online experiences and privacy rights is continually negotiated.
Peter Ibarra, head of adtech solutions at Amperity, a Customer Data Platform (CDP) provider, told CMSWire that most importantly, the deprecation of third-party cookies by Google will change the way consumer data is used online. "With fewer third-party tracking cookies, there’s less opportunity for widespread tracking of user behavior across different websites," said Ibarra. "This shift means consumers have more control over their personal data by allowing users to opt in vs. opt out of data sharing." Ibarra expects that this will force companies to explore new consent incentives and test alternative tracking methods.
Anjali Yakkundi, VP of product marketing at Movable Ink, a digital marketing platform provider, told CMSWire that the decline of cookies is shifting power back to the consumer, becoming a top priority for both tech companies and brands. "In today's landscape, it's essential for brands to obtain consent and foster a relationship with their customers, focusing on what's truly valuable to them. This approach will serve as a guiding principle for brands in the years to come. This is the new normal."
Related Article: First-Party Data: Getting Creative for Cross-Channel Identification
The Impact on Current Data Compliance
The phasing out of third-party cookies significantly impacts current data compliance strategies, pushing businesses to reassess and perhaps overhaul their data handling practices. This change aligns closely with the global trend toward more stringent data privacy regulations, which emphasize user consent and transparency in data collection and usage. Brands are now compelled to shift toward first-party data strategies, where data collection is more direct and consent-driven, requiring clear communication with customers about data practices.
"Elimination of third-party cookies will significantly alter the data compliance landscape. Companies will need to focus more on obtaining explicit consent for data collection while aligning with a mishmash of regulations across geographic regions with GDPR and CCPA," said Ibarra. "This shift could also prompt new regulations specifically addressing alternative tracking technologies and first-party data collection practices to ensure the data company is consensually provided."
Ibarra suggested that companies should revisit their data governance policies to ensure compliance with privacy regulations and ethical standards. “This includes implementing robust consent management systems, ensuring compliance, and being transparent about data collection and usage practices.”
The Impact on Digital Advertising and Marketing Strategies
Without the granular tracking facilitated by third-party cookies, advertisers face challenges in delivering hyper-targeted ads, potentially leading to reduced ad relevance and effectiveness. This change is also driving a greater reliance on first-party data, forcing companies to strengthen direct customer relationships and gather consent-based data.
“The loss of third-party cookies will completely disrupt the digital media ecosystem,” said Ibarra. “While most advertisers think about third-party cookies in the context of targeting, they are used across a variety of tools that span data collection, audience segmentation, data onboarding and, most importantly, measurement.” Ibarra said that there is no silver bullet to replace the third-party cookie, and advertisers have the opportunity to reimagine their digital media tech stack. “In fact, we’re seeing that brands who leave the cookie environment now are experiencing a competitive advantage and will continue to do so since most of the industry has not shifted their reliance from 3P cookies.”
This shift represents a move toward more privacy-centric advertising models, requiring marketers to balance effective targeting with evolving privacy norms and customer expectations. “With the gradual depreciation of cookies, brands will increasingly rely on zero- and first-party data to personalize experiences for their customers,” said Yakkundi. “This holds especially true for zero-party data, where customers willingly share their preferences in exchange for optimized marketing communications.”
Many people are concerned that the loss of third-party cookies will adversely affect customer personalization efforts. Yakkundi said that although a lot of people think that a cookie-less world will make it more difficult to personalize, she doesn’t believe that is the case. “It’s an opportunity to move away from the typical approach where you just talk AT customers, pushing you to talk WITH your customers instead,” said Yakkundi. “Today, there’s a feeling that brands are watching and listening to you. They see that you viewed a product and bombard you with communications and ads with that product.” Yakkundi suggested that particularly with AI, brands have the opportunity to take a more personal shopper-like approach, using what they know about their customer to build tailored, curated conversations.
What About Google’s Privacy Sandbox?
Google's Privacy Sandbox initiative represents a transformative approach in the realm of digital advertising, aiming to safeguard user privacy while still allowing for personalized advertising. This initiative is Google's response to the growing concerns around user data privacy, particularly in the context of third-party cookies which have traditionally been used for tracking user behavior across the web.
The Privacy Sandbox proposes a suite of tools and technologies that enable advertisers to deliver relevant ads and measure their effectiveness without infringing on individual user privacy. Central to this initiative are new frameworks and APIs, such as the Federated Learning of Cohorts (FLoC) and Private State Tokens, previously known as the Trust Token API, which intend to provide privacy-preserving alternatives to the cookie-based tracking system. These technologies are designed to group users into larger cohorts based on similar browsing behaviors, allowing advertisers to target ads without accessing individual user data, thereby striking a balance between personalized advertising and user privacy.
NextRoll, a San Francisco-based marketing technology company, was recently announced as a market testing grantee for Google's Privacy Sandbox initiative, marking a significant move in the realm of online advertising. Having previously contributed to the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) on Google's privacy enhancements, NextRoll is now set to actively test Google's new APIs, including the Protected Audience, Topics, and Attribution Reporting APIs, in the first half of 2024. Such relationships are vital for the continual enhancement and development of privacy-first initiatives that provide businesses with new marketing and advertising opportunities.
The Challenges of Cookie-less Data Collection
Google's ongoing removal of third-party cookies presents brands with several potential challenges. One major challenge is the loss of detailed customer tracking and insights. Third-party cookies have been a staple in understanding customer behaviors and preferences across different websites. Another challenge is the impact on advertising effectiveness. Third-party cookies have enabled businesses to deliver precise, personalized advertising to potential customers.
Businesses are also grappling with the need to bolster their first-party data collection. With the decline of third-party data, collecting data directly from customers through interactions on their own platforms becomes crucial. Additionally, there's a challenge in maintaining customer privacy and trust. As businesses shift their focus to first-party data, they need to ensure they're transparent about their data practices and compliance with privacy regulations.
“Companies face fundamental challenges, such as the need to invest in new technologies for first-party data collection and the potential reduction in the amount of available consumer data,” said Ibarra. “This new reality will present opportunities, including building more direct and meaningful relationships with customers, gaining accurate and relevant data that can inform customer interactions, and enhancing brand trust and credibility.”
Many brands are actively searching for new or reappropriated sources for consumer data. Email quickly comes to mind, as although the media has lost some of its popularity over the years, it remains a regularly used communication and marketing medium for both consumers and businesses. According to a recent Statista report, in 2022, an estimated 4.26 billion people used email, and by 2026, that number is expected to reach 4.73 billion.
Webinar
Sep
25
CMS Briefing: A Live Look at What’s Next in AI-Driven Platforms
Learn how leading organizations are using AI‑driven tools to publish faster, personalize smarter and stay secure.
Register
Webinar
Sep
25
Call Spoofing Trends Financial Institutions Can't Afford to Ignore
Don't let robocalls sabotage your customer relationships. Learn how to secure your voice channel.
Register
Webinar
On demand
Ready or Not: How Data-First Organizations Are Unlocking Agentforce Potential
Learn how to cut through the noise, activate Agentforce and build a Salesforce AI strategy that actually delivers.
Watch Now
Webinar
On demand
CX Reality Check: What Your Customers Are Really Thinking
Register now and get the insights you need to not just meet rising expectations, but exceed them.
Watch Now
Webinar
On demand
Content Leaders Collective: What a Good CCMS Actually Looks Like
Discover how content leaders transform clunky systems into growth engines — and why your competitors are ahead.
Watch Now
Webinar
On demand
From Hype to High-Impact CX Strategies That Actually Scale
Turn buzzworthy AI and outsourcing trends into measurable CX wins with fresh 2025 data.
Watch Now
Jon Beck, CRO of LiveIntent, a buying and selling advertising platform, told CMSWire that as a result of the loss of third-party cookies, businesses will be turning to logged-in channels such as email to build owned audiences and direct relationships. "Unlike other channels that rely on unpredictable algorithms, email thrives outside of those data-hogging walled gardens — and it’s emerged as an excellent source of first-party data." Beck explained that email data can scale across the ecosystem and provide a foundation of interoperable IDs, giving brands the power to understand their audiences and fuel growth even once third-party cookies go away.
Not everyone is in agreement, however. A recent Adlook survey of over 1,000 US consumers revealed that 48% firmly oppose sharing their emails for ad targeting. The use of email for marketing must come with transparency and an understanding of consumer data privacy, something the survey indicated is largely misunderstood, with 3-in-4 respondents either not fully grasping or only partly understanding the changes to privacy policies that came with the loss of third-party cookies.
"Many in our industry see hashed email as a cookie solution, yet consumers remain reluctant to trade emails for ads,” said Patrick Gut, VP of US at Adlook. “Email addresses are becoming more difficult to manage given PII concerns, dummy accounts, and beyond."
Final Thoughts
As Google proceeds with phasing out third-party cookies in Chrome, the industry is being forced to confront a transformation that is centered on privacy and consent. While posing immediate challenges in reach and targeting, this shift compels innovation in first-party data strategies and alternative tracking methods that are aligned with evolving regulations. Though uncertainties remain, the demise of the cookie underscores that the future of digital advertising will be defined by creative solutions that earn consumer trust through respect, rather than surveillance.
