Feature
The Gist
- AI efficiency. Automated responses and data analysis streamline customer service operations, enhancing satisfaction and speed.
- Human empathy. Emotional intelligence and personalized interactions are irreplaceable for complex issues, strengthening customer relationships.
- Balanced approach. Combining AI's data insights with human problem-solving creates a powerful synergy in customer service.
Customer service has evolved to meet consumers' ever-increasing demands. While artificial intelligence (AI) has revolutionized the way businesses interact with their customers, the human touch remains an irreplaceable element in delivering exceptional service. T
he challenge lies in striking the right balance between leveraging AI's efficiency and maintaining the empathetic, personalized interactions only human agents can provide. As companies strive to enhance their customer experience, mastering this balance is crucial.
This article explores how integrating AI with human expertise creates a powerful synergy that elevates customer service to new heights.
Introduction to AI in Customer Service
Customer service has undergone a remarkable transformation over the past few decades. From traditional face-to-face interactions and phone support, it has evolved to include digital channels such as email, live chat and social media. The advent of AI has further changed the dynamics of customer service, introducing automated chatbots and virtual assistants capable of handling a wide range of customer inquiries with impressive efficiency.
However, as customer expectations continue to rise, the need for a balanced approach that integrates both AI and human agents becomes increasingly apparent.
Integrating AI and human agents in customer service is crucial for delivering an exceptional customer experience. AI excels in providing quick, data-driven responses, handling routine queries and offering 24/7 availability. These capabilities significantly enhance operational efficiency and customer satisfaction. However, the human touch remains indispensable for addressing complex issues, offering empathy and building strong customer relationships. Human agents bring emotional intelligence, nuanced understanding and personalized interactions that AI cannot fully replicate.
Laura Stash, executive VP of solutions architecture at iTech AG, a technology consulting firm serving federal, state, and private organizations, shared with CMSWire her vision of AI’s transformative impact on customer service and customer experience (CX) within the federal government. However, she emphasized the irreplaceable value of human interaction. "It’s essential for businesses to keep the human touch alive while leveraging AI technology. While AI can handle a lot of tasks, it’s the human ability to empathize and connect emotionally that makes a significant difference."
Related Article: Combine AI and the Human Touch for Exceptional Customer Service
The Role of AI in Customer Service
AI has significantly transformed customer service, introducing a range of advanced technologies that streamline operations and enhance customer satisfaction. Among these technologies, chatbots stand out for their ability to provide real-time responses to customer inquiries. These AI-powered virtual assistants are designed to simulate human conversation, handling tasks such as answering frequently asked questions, guiding users through processes and completing transactions efficiently.
Automated response systems further enhance customer service by providing pre-programmed answers to the most common questions, allowing human agents to focus on more complex issues. Predictive analytics, another powerful AI tool, anticipates customer needs and behaviors by analyzing past interactions and data, enabling proactive problem-solving and personalized recommendations.
The benefits of AI in customer service are manifold. One of the most significant advantages is efficiency; AI reduces the time needed to resolve customer issues by automating routine tasks and providing instant responses. This leads to faster resolution times and higher customer satisfaction.
Ray Rahmati, senior director of product marketing at Khoros, a customer engagement platform provider, told CMSWire that he expects to see expanded use of AI for business use cases like scalability, automation of repeatable tasks and completion of specific activities. "According to Gartner, brands implementing AI in their service channels are expected to see a significant boost in efficiency by 2025,” said Rahmati. “The global AI chatbot market alone is on track to surpass a valuation of $455 million by 2027."
Additionally, AI systems operate 24/7, offering continuous support without the limitations of human working hours, ensuring that customers receive assistance whenever they need it. AI also excels in data analysis, processing vast amounts of information quickly to extract valuable insights that can inform customer service strategies. This data-driven approach helps businesses better understand customer preferences and behaviors, enabling more personalized interactions.
Several companies have successfully implemented AI in their customer service operations. Sephora, for instance, uses AI-powered chatbots to offer personalized beauty advice and product recommendations. These chatbots interact with customers through the Sephora app and website, providing tailored suggestions based on individual preferences and past purchases.
H&M has also integrated AI-driven chatbots on its online platform to assist customers with order tracking, returns and product inquiries, streamlining its customer service operations and providing quick, accurate responses.
Similarly, Bank of America’s virtual assistant, Erica, helps customers manage their finances, track spending, and answer banking queries, and has handled 2 billion interactions, helping 42 million clients since launch. Using natural language processing (NLP), Erica understands and responds to customer requests.
The use of AI in these roles is expected to increase, along with a corresponding rise in the complexity of AI applications. “As the role of AI in customer service grows, brands will become more discerning about the technology providers they work with, the goals they want to achieve, and how these AI capabilities are implemented within their operations,” said Rahmati.
Related Article: Trust in AI: Combining AI & the Human Experience
The Irreplaceable Human Touch
The irreplaceable human touch remains a cornerstone of customer service when it comes to building meaningful and lasting customer relationships. Empathy, emotional intelligence and personalized interactions are crucial elements that human agents bring to the table:
- Empathy allows agents to understand and share the feelings of their customers, creating a connection that goes beyond mere problem-solving.
- Emotional intelligence enables them to navigate complex emotional landscapes, providing support and understanding in ways that automated systems cannot.
- Personalized interactions, where agents tailor their responses to the unique needs and circumstances of each customer, significantly enhance the customer experience.
“Empathy and emotional intelligence are a crucial piece of customer service,” said Stash. “Training AI to recognize when to hand over to a human agent is vital. For instance, AI can handle straightforward queries but should pass on more sensitive or complex issues to a human who can address them with the necessary empathy and understanding.”
There are numerous situations where human agents are indispensable. When dealing with complex issues that require nuanced understanding and problem-solving skills, human agents can offer the depth of knowledge and flexibility that automated systems often lack. Sensitive topics, such as complaints about serious service failures or issues involving personal or emotional distress, require the delicate handling that only a human can provide. Emotional support is another critical area; customers seeking comfort and reassurance during stressful or challenging times benefit greatly from the warmth and empathy that human agents offer.
“Creating a seamless transition between AI and human agents is another important aspect,” said Stash. “Customers should never feel like they are stuck talking to a machine. Businesses can ensure that there is always a clear and easy way for customers to reach a human when needed. This keeps the interaction flexible and responsive to customer needs.”
Case studies vividly demonstrate the impact of human agents on customer satisfaction. For example, Zappos, renowned for its exceptional customer service, empowers its agents to go above and beyond to meet customer needs. One notable instance involved an agent spending several hours on the phone with a customer to help them find a pair of shoes that fit their specific requirements, ultimately earning the customer's loyalty and trust.
Another example is Ritz-Carlton, where employees are trained to anticipate and fulfill the unexpressed wishes of their guests, often leading to memorable and emotionally resonant experiences that automated systems could never replicate. These case studies highlight the profound difference that empathetic, emotionally intelligent human interactions can make in enhancing customer satisfaction and loyalty.
The Synergy of AI and Human Agents
The synergy between AI and human agents in customer service can create a powerful, efficient and empathetic customer experience. AI can support and enhance human agents by providing valuable data insights and handling routine inquiries. By analyzing customer data, AI systems can identify patterns, predict customer needs, and offer insights that help human agents make more informed decisions. This enables agents to focus on complex and nuanced issues that require human judgment and empathy. For instance, AI can quickly gather and present relevant customer information to agents during an interaction, allowing them to personalize their responses and resolve issues more effectively.
Webinar
Sep
25
CMS Briefing: A Live Look at What’s Next in AI-Driven Platforms
Learn how leading organizations are using AI‑driven tools to publish faster, personalize smarter and stay secure.
Register
Webinar
Sep
25
Call Spoofing Trends Financial Institutions Can't Afford to Ignore
Don't let robocalls sabotage your customer relationships. Learn how to secure your voice channel.
Register
Webinar
On demand
Ready or Not: How Data-First Organizations Are Unlocking Agentforce Potential
Learn how to cut through the noise, activate Agentforce and build a Salesforce AI strategy that actually delivers.
Watch Now
Webinar
On demand
CX Reality Check: What Your Customers Are Really Thinking
Register now and get the insights you need to not just meet rising expectations, but exceed them.
Watch Now
Webinar
On demand
Content Leaders Collective: What a Good CCMS Actually Looks Like
Discover how content leaders transform clunky systems into growth engines — and why your competitors are ahead.
Watch Now
Webinar
On demand
From Hype to High-Impact CX Strategies That Actually Scale
Turn buzzworthy AI and outsourcing trends into measurable CX wins with fresh 2025 data.
Watch Now
“AI has a big role in ensuring the customer experience still feels human by utilizing AI for supporting roles more effectively,” said Stash. “For example, AI can provide agents with relevant information and context during customer interactions, allowing them to respond more effectively and efficiently. This way, the customer still gets a personal touch, but the agent is better equipped to help.”
Effective collaboration between AI and human agents involves strategic integration where each plays to its strengths. One strategy is to use AI as the first point of contact, managing routine inquiries and simple tasks such as password resets, order tracking and FAQs. This not only speeds up response times but also frees up human agents to tackle more intricate and emotionally charged interactions. Another strategy is to employ AI as a support tool for agents, offering real-time suggestions and information during customer interactions. This can include providing agents with recommended responses, next-best actions or even highlighting potential upsell opportunities based on customer data.
“At iTech AG, we focus on integrating AI in a way that supports and enhances human capabilities,” said Stash. “We believe that by prioritizing empathy, personalization, and seamless transitions between AI and human interactions, businesses can maintain that essential human touch while still benefiting from the efficiencies AI offers.”
Several tools and platforms facilitate this integration, ensuring seamless collaboration between AI and human agents. Platforms such as Zendesk and Salesforce have integrated AI capabilities that assist agents by automating routine tasks and offering insights from customer data. Zendesk’s AI features, for example, include Answer Bot, which handles simple queries and passes more complex issues to human agents. Salesforce’s Einstein AI provides predictive analytics and customer insights to help agents personalize their interactions and resolve issues more efficiently.
Devin Daly, CEO of Impel, an automotive AI-powered customer lifecycle management solution provider, told CMSWire that AI will increasingly be the catalyst and foundation of customer service, enabling organizations to deliver a personalized customer experience that is engaging, and instantly responsive, at a scale previously unobtainable — and impossible with human personnel. Thanks to the synergy of AI and live agents, "The human service agent of the future will be more efficient, more tech-savvy and forward-thinking, understanding how to work seamlessly with AI-enabled technologies and applications to increase their productivity and results," said Daly.
Challenges and Considerations
Relying too heavily on either AI or human agents alone in customer service presents several potential pitfalls. AI, while efficient and capable of handling routine inquiries, lacks the emotional intelligence necessary for managing complex or sensitive situations. Over-reliance on AI can lead to impersonal interactions and customer frustration when their issues require empathy and nuanced understanding that AI cannot provide. Conversely, depending solely on human agents can result in slower response times and higher operational costs, as human resources are inherently limited in their availability and scalability.
Richard Wirth, faculty member at Harrisburg University of Science and Technology in Pennsylvania, told CMSWire that applications for AI in customer service are evolving rapidly, but they require careful consideration and thoughtful implementation to make a positive impact.
"Currently, the major concern among customers is that the significant pressure for more companies to adopt AI will further remove the human element from services," said Wirth, who cited a December 2023 Gartner survey that revealed that 60% of respondents feared that the rapid push for AI solutions will "make it more difficult to reach a person," topping concerns about AI replacing jobs (46%) and AI making errors (42%).
Balancing cost and efficiency with the quality of service is another critical consideration. AI systems can significantly reduce operational costs by automating routine tasks and providing 24/7 support, however, achieving the right balance requires integrating AI in a way that complements and enhances human capabilities rather than replacing them. For example, AI can handle initial customer interactions and gather preliminary information, allowing human agents to step in when more complex, personalized support is needed. This approach ensures that efficiency gains do not come at the expense of service quality.
"Perhaps most critical to success is the adoption of AI at scale across the entire ecosystem,” emphasized Daly. “Using AI in silos within the tech stack or for narrow applications undermines the value and power of AI— and usually results in a disparate patchwork of tools, increased human workload, higher costs, and a sub-optimal customer experience.” Daly suggested that businesses should adopt AI platforms that unify their tech stack, consolidate data and processes, and establish a unified corporate voice across all of the channels and touchpoints of the customer journey.
“Additionally, businesses should ensure a thoughtful and deliberate integration of AI and human workflows across all systems and processes, so that AI-human interaction is consistent, complementary, never duplicative or disruptive, and seamless to the customer,” said Daly. “Simply ‘layering on’ AI on top of established human-only workflows and processes will lead to confusion and duplication of effort, frustration for both employees and customers, sabotage of the AI platform by apprehensive team members, and even more organizational ‘drag.’”
Ethical considerations and customer trust are paramount when integrating AI into customer service. Transparency in AI usage is crucial; customers need to know when they are interacting with AI versus a human agent. This transparency helps in maintaining trust and managing customer expectations. Privacy and data security are also significant concerns, as AI systems often handle large amounts of sensitive customer data. Companies must ensure robust data protection measures are in place to prevent breaches and misuse of information. Additionally, AI systems should be designed to avoid biases and ensure fair treatment of all customers, as biased algorithms can lead to discriminatory practices and erode customer trust.
“While AI has the potential to become a seamless, highly efficient experience that offers many advantages for companies and customers alike, the ultimate goal should be accomplishing this without losing sight of who is affected by this new and exciting tool,” suggested Wirth. “The most significant step in the adoption of AI thus needs to be the building-in of trust as a solution that supports and empowers all stakeholders.”
Final Thoughts on AI-Human Customer Service Balance
Mastering the balance between AI and human touch in customer service is essential for businesses striving to succeed in the current competitive environment. By leveraging AI's efficiency and data-driven insights alongside human empathy and problem-solving skills, companies can create a powerful synergy that enhances customer experiences. This balanced approach not only improves operational efficiency but also builds stronger customer relationships and loyalty.
