Editorial
The Gist
- The Power of Presentation. Choice architecture subtly guides customer behavior by framing decisions without limiting freedom.
- AI as the Nudge Engine. Artificial intelligence can personalize and optimize these decision cues in real time.
- Defaults Simplify Decisions. Pre-selected or suggested options reduce friction and make engagement effortless across digital channels.
- Decoys Drive Value Perception. Intentionally less appealing options make other choices seem better — now scalable through AI.
You’re racing to the store, dashing down the aisle. Today's the big Fourth of July BBQ and you forgot hamburger buns. Hold up! You spot an endcap stacked with graham crackers, marshmallows and chocolate bars. Suddenly, s’mores feel like the perfect addition to the party! Each item is a familiar name brand, the kind you usually skip for a cheaper option. But it’s easier to just grab the pre-arranged combination. Before you know it, all the ingredients are in your cart.
This is choice architecture, the subtle art of influencing decisions through presentation. CX professionals use it to shape how customers move through experiences both online and in store. And with AI in the mix, those nudges can become smarter, faster and more personalized than ever before.
Table of Contents
- What Is Choice Architecture and How Does it Relate to CX?
- How AI Elevates Choice Architecture
- Defaults In Action
- Decoys and the Power of Comparison
- Applying Behavioral Design to CX Strategy
What Is Choice Architecture and How Does it Relate to CX?
Let’s start with a definition. In behavioral economics, choice architecture is the idea that how options are presented to people influences their decisions, without restricting freedom of choice. By organizing, highlighting or structuring choices in certain ways, cx professionals can guide behavior, reduce decision fatigue and make desired outcomes easier to achieve.
How AI Elevates Choice Architecture
There are many tools in the choice architecture toolkit, but two are particularly useful: defaults and decoys.
- Defaults are pre-selected or recommended options that people are more likely to choose simply because they’re presented as the standard or easiest path. In the s’mores example, the store’s choice to display familiar name brands positioned them as the default option.
- Decoys are options intentionally designed to be less attractive, making another choice appear more appealing. Imagine that same endcap offering two chocolate bar sizes: a regular bar and a larger one that costs only slightly more. The smaller, less attractive bar frames the larger one as the better value, nudging shoppers toward it.
While defaults and decoys have long guided decisions in physical spaces like grocery stores, digital customer experience offers even more opportunities to shape choice, especially when powered by AI. By analyzing user behavior, preferences and context in real time, AI can shape certain options as seamless or more appealing, reducing decision fatigue and boosting engagement.
Related Article: Reinventing Digital Experience Design: Core Skills for the Human AI Era
Defaults In Action
From subscription sign-ups to product recommendations, thoughtfully-designed defaults and decoys can help customers make faster, more satisfying choices.
Defaults Deep Dive
Defaults are pre-selected or recommended options that people are more likely to choose simply because they are presented as the standard or easiest path. They leverage convenience and habit, simplifying consumer decisions.
Think about the last time you paid for a meal or a ride-share. The receipt most likely shared pre-calculated tip amounts: 15%, 18% or 20%. And one highlighted as the suggested option. Even if you normally tip differently, many people simply accept the default because it’s quick and easy. This is a classic example of a default in action: a pre-selected option subtly guiding behavior.
Defaults like these are everywhere, from subscription sign-ups to software settings, and they illustrate how small nudges can significantly influence decisions. AI takes this principle further by designing defaults to be dynamic and relevant across the customer journey:
- Lead Generation / Personalization Across Channels AI can pre-select content, messaging or product recommendations for new or returning users based on past behavior, referral source or engagement patterns.
- Landing Pages / Product Selection Adaptive product or content defaults make it effortless for users to engage. AI can highlight the items or categories they are most likely to click, based on past purchases, browsing behavior, or content interaction.
- Checkout / Forms Auto-filled forms remove friction by pre-populating shipping info, payment methods and other key fields. AI can even suggest quantities, sizes, or add-ons aligned with prior behavior, streamlining the purchase process.
- Retention / Recurring Purchases CX teams can use AI to optimize recurring orders, renewals and replenishment reminders. By analyzing timing, usage and communication preferences, AI ensures defaults feel helpful and tailored to their needs.
Decoys and the Power of Comparison
By integrating AI-driven defaults, businesses can streamline decision-making, reduce friction and subtly guide customers toward choices that enhance their experience.
Decoys Deep Dive
Decoys are options intentionally designed to be less attractive than another choice, making the preferred option appear more appealing. They work by leveraging relative comparisons.
Consider a trip to the movie theater. You’re at the counter, looking at three popcorn sizes: small, medium and large. The prices go up gradually, but the large comes with free refills. Most moviegoers skip the medium as it’s just slightly overpriced for the portion. That middle option isn’t really meant to sell; it’s there to make the large look like the best value. And the funny part? You probably won’t even go for a refill. AI allows businesses to extend the power of decoys across the entire customer journey.
Here’s how it can be applied:
- First Touch / Landing Page Starting at a dynamic landing page, AI can not only assess what your customers are most likely to engage with based on past purchases or search behavior. AI can also arrange options to make the target choice visually prominent by including a slightly less attractive decoy.
- Bundling / Package Stage Once your customer starts putting items in the cart, AI can dynamically generate bundles tailored to predicted user needs, while CX professionals can strategically insert decoy bundles to make the target bundle more appealing.
- Add-Ons and Enhancements Stage Even after the main selection, AI can present decoy options for add-ons or upgrades to encourage higher-value choices, longer subscriptions and peace of mind offers.
By strategically applying decoys with AI, businesses can guide customer decisions at multiple touchpoints in a way that feels effortless and satisfying.
Related Article: CX Leaders Bet on AI, Yet Trust and Transparency Remain the Wildcards
Applying Behavioral Design to CX Strategy
By thoughtfully applying defaults and decoys, businesses can create customer experiences that feel effortless, intuitive and personalized. When powered by AI, these behavioral economics principles become even more powerful, guiding users toward the choices that maximize customer satisfaction and engagement while preserving freedom of choice.
Webinar
Nov
6
Fix the Content Bottleneck: Build a Better WebOps Strategy
Content stalled? Dev overloaded? You’re not the only one. Learn how streamlined WebOps bridges the publishing gap.
Register
Webinar
Nov
13
Know Your Caller Reputation: How to Protect Your Brand and Get More Calls Answered
80% of unidentified calls go unanswered. See why your calls aren’t getting through.
Register
Webinar
Nov
20
How to Build a Solid Knowledge Foundation for AI Success
See how leading brands keep their AI honest, compliant and actually helpful.
Register
Webinar
Dec
2
From Manual to Magical: How AI Transforms CX Teams
Learn how to replace manual support processes with automation that actually delivers.
Register
Webinar
Dec
9
Rebrand. Migrate. Optimize. How to Do It All (Without Slowing Down)
Cresta leveled up site speed, design flexibility and marketer sanity (in record time). Find out how.
Register
Webinar
On demand
Beyond Storage: Smarter Content, Bigger Impact with DAM + AI
Discover how the DAM + AI duo makes content smarter, stronger and more accessible.
Watch Now
From first impressions on landing pages to checkout, bundles, and recurring interactions, defaults and decoys can reduce friction, increase conversion and elevate the overall experience. If you’re ready to explore how AI-driven choice architecture can transform your CX strategy, start experimenting with defaults and decoys today and see how small nudges can deliver big results.
Learn how you can join our contributor community.
