Editorial
White Paper
How Enterprise Legal Teams Are Rethinking How Matters Get Managed
The Gist
- Price is no longer the battleground. Rising grocery costs and shifting consumer behavior make price-led strategies unsustainable, forcing brands to compete on perceived value instead.
- Speed and insight define competitive advantage. Brands that leverage real-time data, AI and faster feedback loops outperform those stuck in slow, siloed decision-making models.
- Measurement and strategy must evolve together. New KPIs focused on value perception, omnichannel behavior and efficiency are essential to navigate a fragmented, value-driven market.
In economically uncertain times, it would seem safe to assume the best way to win over customers hinges on this uncertainty. Yet, relying on price as a primary market differentiator is growing increasingly unsustainable for CPG brands. This is no longer a theoretical concern, but an operational reality.
In Zappi’s latest CPG Mega-Trends Report, 80% of shoppers say their grocery bill has gone up within the past six months. As many as 25% of households are spending over $250/week at the grocery store. Consumer Packaged Goods companies looking to drive price-led growth will face tough headwinds. Shoppers are savvier, smarter and more value-conscious than they’ve been in the past decade — all while taking bigger swings of the economic boom/bust pendulum.
These findings mean that marketing leaders need to shift their focus from defending existing price points to systematically building perceived value in new and different ways, in a market where established customer loyalty dynamics are shifting.
Let's explore some ways to do this.
Table of Contents
- Frequently Asked Questions About CPG’s Shift From Price to Value
- Portfolio and Product Strategy Shifts That Market Dynamics Demand
- Closing the AI Implementation Gap with a Value-First Operating Model
- Evolving Measurement for Omnichannel Engagement
- Summary: Why Competing on Price Is a Losing Strategy — and What Comes Next
Frequently Asked Questions About CPG’s Shift From Price to Value
Editor’s note: These core questions explore why price-led competition is losing effectiveness and what CPG leaders should prioritize instead to build loyalty, relevance and long-term growth.
Portfolio and Product Strategy Shifts That Market Dynamics Demand
Transitioning from price-led to value-led approaches is critical due to the macroeconomic pressures fundamentally restructuring purchasing decisions. For instance, value now supersedes taste as the main consideration for snack and beverage purchases, with 71% of shoppers prioritizing value compared to 54% who prioritize flavor, according to the research.
There is also an observed decline in exclusive brand preference, with only 10% of consumers now purchasing only brand-name items (a 11-point decrease in six months). At the same time, 66% of consumers purchase a combination of brand and private-label products.
To retain market relevance, brand strategy must adapt to critical market dynamics:
- Portfolio strategy needs to acknowledge the mixed-basket reality, in which national brands compete directly with high-quality store brands.
- Product discovery is now segmented by generation, necessitating a demographic-specific engagement approach.
- Innovation is the most reliable defense against the increasing market share of private labels and emerging competitors.
Brands that have relied on mass-market TV advertising to justify premium prices are likely ceding share to private-label alternatives, which 60% of consumers now assess as equal to or superior in quality. To recapture this market share, these established brands cannot simply continue to reduce prices. Instead, they need to utilize real-time insights to pinpoint specific, functional benefits that store brands cannot easily replicate.
Success going forward will be determined not by market visibility but by the speed at which a brand can substantiate its premium.
Related Article: Is Your Marketing Strategy Built for Economic Uncertainty?
Closing the AI Implementation Gap with a Value-First Operating Model
Driving this value-first initiative demands business-wide reimagination of marketing functions. Research shared that only 6% of CPG decision makers have a strategic plan to map how they will drive business value from AI when 90% stated that AI is important to their business. This risk is exacerbated as AI begins to play a larger role throughout the purchase funnel.
To address this, marketing leadership should concentrate on strategic structural reorganizations:
- Centralize fragmented data functions within a unified growth office to establish a complete view of the consumer.
- Internalize insights and analytics capabilities to reduce concept-to-market timelines by up to 30%.
- Prioritize genuine micro-influencer advocacy to overcome the trust deficit observed on social media platforms.
Take for example swapping out quarterly research cycles for an insights platform. This increases velocity by shortening the feedback loop and allows your team to learn faster. Instead of waiting three months for a consumer sentiment report you can A/B test four different package designs on Monday and make a data-backed decision by Wednesday. With 93% of consumers shifting their shopping habits to fight price inflation speed is of the essence.
Organizations that fail to transition from traditional, siloed data processes to AI-driven systems risk becoming structurally excluded from the emerging commerce ecosystem.
Evolving Measurement for Omnichannel Engagement
Measurement frameworks must also evolve, as current Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) often obscure underlying challenges to brand relevance. Currently, 60% of CPG leaders report a misalignment between their financial reporting and their operational business structure. This lack of visibility impedes innovation and delays critical decision-making.
The research points to four new metrics marketing teams should adopt to track performance across multi-channel environments effectively:
- Perceived Value Rating (PVR): Measures the brand's position relative to the market's value-for-price regression line.
- Omnichannel Penetration: Track the 90% of shoppers who now engage in both in-store and online purchasing.
- Retail Media Yield: Evaluates the return on investment for the over $50 billion spent on retailer advertising platforms.
- Workflow Efficiency Gains: Quantifies the 25% to 40% improvement in time-to-market realized through AI integration.
Ultimately, future success in the CPG sector will depend on an organization's ability to bridge the gap between vast consumer datasets and actionable business intelligence. By moving toward a real-time, data-driven decision-making model, brands can better navigate the complexities of omnichannel shopping and maintain a competitive edge in an increasingly volatile market.
Webinar
Apr
14
The State of Enterprise Site Search: From Basic Utility to Strategic Advantage
Join CMSWire and SearchStax for a conversation about how enterprise IT and marketing leaders are moving beyond basic site search.
Register
Webinar
Apr
16
AI Adoption Roadmap: The Tech Traps Nobody is Talking About
Lagging on AI progress? Join this webinar to accelerate safely — without disrupting your current platforms.
Register
Webinar
Apr
21
From Broken to Built for CX: Modernizing the Back Office
Most CX organizations already know where the problem lives. The ones pulling ahead have figured out what to do about it.
Register
Webinar
Apr
22
Why Your AI Media Stack Is Leaking Revenue — And What Fixes It
Stop layering AI on a broken foundation and start building the operating model that makes every media investment compound.
Register
Webinar
Apr
23
AI for Your DXP: Connect What You Have, Transform How You Work
Most AI strategies stop at the platform—but work happens elsewhere. Bring intelligence into Teams, email, tickets and CRM.
Register
Webinar
Apr
27
Where Contact Center AI Is Actually Headed
A straight read on where the contact center platform market is going and what it means for your next technology decision.
Register
How CPG Brands Shift From Price Wars to Value Leadership
This table outlines how leading brands are moving beyond price competition toward value-driven growth, faster decision-making and stronger customer loyalty.
| Area | Old Approach | New Reality | What CX Leaders Should Do |
|---|---|---|---|
| Competitive Strategy | Compete on price and promotions | Compete on perceived value and differentiation | Clearly define and communicate unique product benefits that justify premium positioning |
| Consumer Behavior | Strong brand loyalty | Mixed baskets of brand and private label | Design experiences that reinforce trust and repeat purchase beyond price incentives |
| Product Strategy | Mass-market, one-size-fits-all | Segmented discovery and targeted innovation | Align offerings to generational and behavioral preferences using real-time insights |
| AI and Data Usage | Siloed analytics and slow research cycles | Real-time, AI-driven decision-making | Centralize data and accelerate testing to shorten time-to-market |
| Speed to Insight | Quarterly reporting cycles | Continuous testing and rapid iteration | Adopt always-on insights platforms to enable faster decisions |
| Measurement | Traditional KPIs (sales, margin) | Value-based and omnichannel metrics | Track perceived value, omnichannel engagement and workflow efficiency |
| Brand Trust | Built through advertising scale | Built through authenticity and advocacy | Leverage micro-influencers and real customer signals to strengthen credibility |
Summary: Why Competing on Price Is a Losing Strategy — and What Comes Next
Entrenched competitive strategies based on price-led approaches can be difficult to move beyond. Still, to avoid a race to the bottom and a potentially impossible-to-win scenario, brands instead should focus on the areas where they can build perceived value and grow loyalty that extends the definition of "value" beyond being solely cost-based.
Brands that succeed in the next decade will stop trying to compete primarily on price. They will out-innovate one another with real-time, connected intelligence and earn trust and loyalty from consumers who are more price sensitive than ever.
Learn how you can join our contributor community.