<p>The past decade has seen a dramatic increase in organizations being taken to court over issues of accessibility on their websites and mobile apps. According to the <a rel="noopener noreferrer" href="https://www.cdc.gov/ncbddd/disabilityandhealth/infographic-disability-impacts-all.html" target="_blank" title="CDC">CDC</a>, 26% of the US adult population is living with a disability. This figure is expected to increase as the baby boomer generation continues to age. </p>  <p>As the number of people with disabilities grows, the number of Website ADA compliance lawsuits is sure to grow along with that. Brands need to take note now of ways they can stay out of litigation. </p>  <p>I had the opportunity to speak with an expert on this topic, Steve Barnes, who is the president of <a rel="noopener noreferrer" href="https://www.barnescreativestudios.com/" target="_blank" title="Barnes Creative Studios">Barnes Creative Studios</a>. Barnes specializes in adding accessibility to one of the most difficult pieces of the website puzzle… third-party media.</p>  <h2>Why Do Brands Need to Know About Web Accessibility?</h2> <p><strong>Barnes:</strong> Brands need to know that there is no quick fix and non-compliance can be costly as one in four of the market has a disability of some kind. Why would you not want to interact with them? The journey should start with proper education on what they need to do with their websites. There are many outlets that can help with proper guidance. Don’t fall for the ad at the top of your latest search for accessibility.</p><div class="article-body-ad-placeholder">{"gptAdId":"testId"}</div>  <p>Brands also need to realize that a website fix does not address third party elements like Matterport virtual tours, YouTube videos, etc. The latter being very important for a large number of websites. Content is the fuel that drives context on a website. That same context needs to get through to disabled users when they use your website. This means fixing your website means “fixing” everything on your website. If a lawsuit comes your way and you just fix the text elements and alt tags…they can come back again and attack what you left not remediated. It is so much cheaper to address accessibility from the start.</p><p><strong>Related Article: <a rel="noopener noreferrer" href="https://www.cmswire.com/digital-experience/designing-diversity-inclusion-and-accessibility-into-web3/" target="_blank" title="Designing Diversity, Inclusion and Accessibility Into Web3">Designing Diversity, Inclusion and Accessibility Into Web3</a></strong></p>  <h2>What Are the Ramifications of Not Complying?</h2> <p><strong>Barnes:</strong> Defendants in ADA lawsuits typically pay plaintiff's legal fees, defense costs, plus their own web accessibility auditing and remediation expenses. Brand sentiment is another factor that should be considered as the legal action against a sensitive group could lead to significant brand damage.</p>  <p>If you believe the internet, the path to accessibility is a simple line of code added to a website for $49 a month. This is a tool referred to as an “overlay.” At this time, the overlay is not a wise choice and considered by many in the accessibility community as snake oil. Companies are expected to spend <a rel="noopener noreferrer" href="https://www.wsj.com/articles/adp-settlement-offers-framework-for-future-digital-accessibility-agreements-11642699462" target="_blank" title="$10 billion dollars">$10 billion</a>&nbsp;this year on design vendors and service providers that provide accessible solutions, according to Forrester.</p>  <p>Case in point: for multiple years blind advocates were filing many complaints against the payroll powerhouse ADP. Instead of properly fixing accessibility issues which is costly, they chose to install said overlay. Plaintiff’s took them to court with the complaint and <a rel="noopener noreferrer" href="https://sheribyrnehaber.medium.com/more-lawsuits-filed-against-companies-using-accessibility-plugin-overlays-1cc539d493b2" target="_blank" title="were claiming">were claiming</a> they experienced with the overlay:</p>  <ol type="1"><li>Links do not work.</li><li>Screen reader users have difficulty submitting responses.</li><li>Improper reading order.</li><li>Unannounced state changes.</li><li>Edit fields, graphic links, and drop-down menus either unlabeled, inappropriately labeled, or otherwise difficult to interact with.</li><li>Inconsistent organization.</li></ol>       <p>Any one of the plaintiffs’ complaints would be a serious WCAG 2.1 violation.</p>  <p>Disability Rights Advocates (DRA), the firm representing the plaintiff (Lighthouse For The Blind), is well known for groundbreaking cases related to accessibility. These cases include physical access, accessible voting, education, transportation and digital accessibility lawsuits such as White v. Square, NFB v. Scribd, and the granddaddy of digital accessibility litigation, NFB v. Target. Most importantly, DRA is known for cases that make a difference. DRA is not a drive-by accessibility plaintiff firm.</p>  <p>This statement from <a rel="noopener noreferrer" href="https://www.lflegal.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/ADP-and-SF-Lighthouse-settlement-agreement.pdf" target="_blank" title="the settlement">the settlement</a> is important for those using overlays to see:</p>  <p><em>“Accessible” (or “Accessibility” or “Access”) means that blind and low vision individuals have independent access to the same information and equivalent ease of use of functionalities available to sighted individuals via the Website or Mobile Apps. For the purpose of this Agreement, “overlay” solutions such as those currently provided by companies such as AudioEye and AccessiBe will not suffice to achieve Accessibility.</em> </p>  <p>Cases are expensive. In another case, Target agreed to settle a lawsuit alleging that its website was not accessible to the blind, agreeing to improve the website and pay $6 million into a “Damages Fund” for members of the class-action lawsuit. The court also awarded about $3.7 million in attorney fees. The best place to follow what is happening in the courts is the robust digital lawsuit catalog which is up to the month from <a rel="noopener noreferrer" href="https://www.accessibility.com/digital-lawsuits" target="_blank" title="Accessibility.com">Accessibility.com</a>. “Website accessibility lawsuits continue to steadily rise month over month and year over year,” said Reeve Segal, attorney.</p><p>Here are the number of ADA-based cases, where the subject of the claim was either a website, mobile app or video content:</p><ul><li>2018: 2,314</li><li>2019: 2,890</li><li>2020: 3.503</li><li>2021: 4,055</li></ul>  <h2>Q: Is This Applicable to ANY Brand in ANY Industry?</h2> <p><strong>A:</strong> Going straight to the source …&nbsp;<a rel="noopener noreferrer" href="https://beta.ada.gov/web-guidance/" target="_blank" title="ADA.GOV">ADA.gov</a>: “The Americans with Disabilities Act applies to state and local governments (Title II) and businesses that are open to the public (Title III).” Companies are taking to themselves to interpret this information in a myriad of ways. “The Department has consistently taken the position that the ADA’s requirements apply to all the services, programs, or activities of state and local governments, including those offered on the web.”</p>  <p>"Web accessibility is applicable to any business, government agency, or non-profit that interacts with people, provides information, sells goods and or services via the internet,” said John Griffin, publisher, Accessibility.com. “The internet is the touchpoint of the global digital ecosystem that is changing the world. Fully accessible websites are standard to all enterprises." </p>  <p>Moving to businesses that are open to the public is where the big debate begins. “A website with inaccessible features can limit the ability of people with disabilities to access a public accommodation’s goods, services, and privileges available through that website.”</p>  <p>“For these reasons, the Department has consistently taken the position that the ADA’s requirements apply to all the goods, services, privileges, or activities offered by public accommodations, including those offered on the web.” Some of the largest verticals to see legal action are retail, hospitality, travel, universities, and many more.</p>  <p>This is a <a rel="noopener noreferrer" href="https://overlayfactsheet.com/" target="_blank" title="great resource regarding overlays">great resource regarding overlays</a> that was sourced by some of the top names in accessibility. Lots of great quotes at the bottom.</p><div class="article-body-webinars-placeholder">null</div><p><strong>Related Article: <a rel="noopener noreferrer" href="https://www.cmswire.com/digital-experience/why-analytics-accessibility-is-essential-for-designing-digital-customer-experiences/" target="_blank" title="Why Analytics, Accessibility Are Essential for Designing Digital Customer Experiences">Why Analytics, Accessibility Are Essential for Designing Digital Customer Experiences</a></strong></p>  <h2>Q: What's the Proper Way to Comply?</h2> <p><strong>A: </strong>The proper way to comply is to work with a reputable team that truly understands accessibility with websites. A great example would be a company like “Deque” based in <span style="color: rgb(49, 49, 49);">Herndon, Va</span>. Their direction can be a huge saver of cash, reputation and time. </p><p>Accessibility is also not just from a snapshot of time. It is ever changing and evolving with new rules coming any day now with updated WCAG recommendations. Many companies are beginning to establish specific company roles focused on leading the accessibility efforts. Some cases are even seeing it as a part of the settlement to establish a C-Suite level accessibility role.</p>  <p>"Today, companies need to be very cautious about any accessibility solution that claims it will fix all your problems for very little money,” says Glenda Sims of Deque Systems, a technology provider of end to end, integrated Web compliance solutions. “If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is. When I look at the state of digital accessibility today, it is clear that, on average nearly 60% of all accessibility issues (by volume) can be identified with automation. So, there is no way, today, that automation alone can make a web site or native app fully accessible."</p>


<style>

  .video_container_youtube {

    overflow: hidden;

    position: relative;

    width:100%;

}

 

.video_container_youtube::after {

    padding-top: 56.25%;

    display: block;

    content: '';

}

 

.video_container_youtube iframe {

    position: absolute;

    top: 0;

    left: 0;

    width: 100%;

    height: 100%;

}

</style>

 

<div class="video_container_youtube">

  <iframe src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/WK2d6cV8gXA" title="YouTube video player" frameborder="0" allow="accelerometer; autoplay; clipboard-write; encrypted-media; gyroscope; picture-in-picture" allowfullscreen=""></iframe>

</div>  

<h2>Q: How Do You Make Media Accessible?</h2> <p><strong>A:</strong> This one is tricky and just as much work if not more. Media is much more complex. All types of media have to be addressed including images, videos and virtual tours. </p>  <p><strong>Images:</strong> Images must have alt tag meta data that includes descriptions that convey the intended context of the image. This could go many different directions depending on the audience intent for the image. Below is some great info on the topic from The <a rel="noopener noreferrer" href="https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/blog/alt-text-that-informs-meeting-the-needs-of-people-who-are-blind-or-low-vision/" target="_blank" title="Microsoft Ability Initiative">Microsoft Ability Initiative</a>:</p>  <p><em>For example, if a photo of a person appeared in a news story, people might want a description that includes details about the setting of the image to give a sense of place. But if a photo of a person appeared on a social media or dating website, people might want increased details about that person’s appearance, including some details that may be subjective and/or sensitive, such as race, perceived gender, and attractiveness.</em> </p>  <p><strong>Videos: </strong>Making videos accessible involves a few different elements depending on what is represented in a video. If a video is straightforward with just scenes that cut to other scenes with no speaking, there would be less to do. In this case there would be no closed captions because no one is saying anything. There would need to be an audio description track that explained every scene for blind or low vision viewers. This is where complexity starts as you would need a separate player to carry these non-traditional media items. You would also need someone who is able to write for disability which is a specialty form of writing.</p>  <p>A video with people speaking is all of the above but you are now adding in closed captions, transcripts and complex audio descriptions that could include a special version of the video that pauses every time a new scene is introduced.&nbsp; Videos are a very heavy lift and can get expensive for lengthy productions.</p>  <p><strong>Virtual Tours:</strong> This is another highly complicated piece of media because the experience is user driven, and each user viewing the media may have interest in different areas of the virtual tour. The user driven aspect throws a curve ball at web design as there are many elements that need to “ride together” on the page to get you ADA compliant but also not make a mess of your webpage. The same elements from the video implementation above are needed but used in a different way depending on how the user interacts with the virtual tour.</p>  <p>We solved that with <a rel="noopener noreferrer" href="https://www.barnescreativestudios.com/ada-compliant-virtual-tours/" target="_blank" title="360 AG">360 AG</a>™ aka <em>The 360 Accessibility Generator</em>. Barnes Creative Studios is an official partner with Matterport providing accessibility for the highly popular Matterport virtual tours. Matterport is the largest provider of virtual tours with their proprietary virtual tour software. The 360 AG solution rolls all of the necessary elements inside one clean player that is easily added to your webpage with an embed code just like any modern media. There is a lot of work going on behind the scenes to interact with screen readers and provide accessibility for users that need it.</p>  <p>Several years ago I had a large client demanding accessibility for their Matterport virtual tours, and there was no solution that existed. I kept searching and searching and could find nothing. There was a good reason for that as it was a tall task. It became my passion to solve this problem, and we spent a lot of time and money to come up with the solution which is now patent pending. It took many months to do it but we’re thrilled now to be partnered with Matterport helping their users add accessibility to their very popular and useful digital twins.</p>  <p>The biggest message to receive from all this information is that accessibility is going nowhere, and the time to adapt is now. By getting in front of this you can save a lot of money and do the right thing by being inclusive and opening your content to everyone.</p><div class="ink-overlay-container"></div><div class="ink-overlay-container"></div><div class="ink-overlay-container"></div><div class="ink-overlay-container"></div><div class="ink-overlay-container"></div><div class="ink-overlay-container"></div><div class="ink-overlay-container"></div><div class="ink-overlay-container"></div><div class="ink-overlay-container"></div>

Digital Experience

Web Accessibility and What Brands Need to Know: Q&A With Steve Barnes

Feature

eBook

eBooks

The right survey strategy needn’t be complex, but it must be deliberate. This e-book provides you with the four key elements of a brand building survey program.

Customer Experience

How to Make Every Survey a Top Customer Experience

White Paper

White Papers

The rate of change in eCommerce has always been fast. Yes, Covid-19 has come along and put everything into overdrive. But a lot of these external factors were already in play before we even knew Covid existed.

How to Stay Ahead of Ecommerce in 2022 and Beyond

Buyer's Guide

Buyer's Guides

A content style guide is the backbone of your enterprise content strategy — it’s the difference between providing average or incredible experiences for your customers.

Content Style Guide

Research Report

Research Reports

While most organizations still struggle to fully understand their customers, the successful ones are exhibiting technology investment patterns which result in the delivery of superior customer experiences.

The State of Digital Customer Experience

It’s no secret that the most successful companies are able to attract and retain top talent, yet employee experience remains a consistent challenge for many of today’s global enterprises.

Digital Workplace

Employee Retention

Customer Data Platforms Market Guide (2022 Q1)

This market guide examines the current state of the industry for a detailed look at leading vendors that are pushing the limits of what a DXP can do.

Digital Experience Platforms (DXP) Market Guide

Featuring real-world case studies and insights for your organization, this report will help you to deliver, manage and improve your digital workplace, and support your workforce as you navigate what the next phase of working will look like.

The State of the Digital Workplace

Today’s omnichannel customer experience world is proving challenging. Nearly 20% of brands saw a decrease in CX quality. 

Online

Exceptional Omnichannel Customer Experience: What it Looks Like, How to Achieve & Measure it

Are you leveraging deep customer insights to hyper-personalize your communications? Or are you still just talking to a segment?

How to Hyper-Personalize Your Customer Communications Across Channels

Learn how some of the world's most beloved brands are setting the bar for employee engagement.

Unlocking the Power of AI in the Contact Center

Learn why employees are still resigning in 2022

Beat the Great Resignation with Process Improvement

Digital Workplace Experience - Q3 2022

How Great Organizations Empower Customer Experience Teams

Digital Experience Summit  - Q3 2022

Succeeding in the Era of the Intelligent Workplace

Digital Workplace Experience - Q4 2022

Future CX - Blending Physical & Digital Experiences

Digital Experience Summit - Q4 2022

Boost employee engagement and retain workers in a hybrid environment

How to Boost Employee Sentiment in 2022

How Louis Vuitton, Carrefour, Tesco, Pepsi Co., and PVH made the switch to NoSQL

5 Modern Data-Driven Applications That Transformed Employee and Customer Experiences

As hybrid workplaces become the norm, intentionally embracing this new way of working is one key to success.

Empowering and Enabling Teams in the New Hybrid Workspace

Robin recently surveyed 300+ professionals to better understand what great leadership looks like in a hybrid world.

Power Hybrid Work With Tech That Connects

Collaboration and Cooperation: Two Key Elements That Drive Successful DCX

The digital employee experience has never been more critical

2022 State of the Digital Workplace

FHI 360 saves $400k with Intelligent Hardware Refresh

Create Cost-effective Hardware Refresh Cycles

The New Era of Well-Being: How to Realize Your Potential and Succeed at Work & Life

Digital Mental Health Support: Helping Remote Workers Fight Burnout and Loneliness

How creating engaged workplaces drives business impact and delivers optimal customer experiences

Modernized Knowledge Management: The New Driving Force Behind a Great Employee and Customer Experience

How to create a plan that brings collaboration back into the office

Rediscovering Collaboration in the Office

Digital Experience Summit  - Q2 2022

Embracing & Optimizing the Hybrid Workplace

Digital Workplace Experience - Q2 2022

Customer Experience Strategies for an Accelerated Reality

Digital Experience Summit - Q1 2022

Welcome to the New Now of Employee Experience

Digital Workplace Experience - Q1 2022

Keys to ensuring technology platforms are intuitive and accessible for all

Voice of the Employee: Aligning Employee Listening with User Experience Tools and Services

Learn the factors that are important to employees as they evaluate new job prospects

Hiring New Talent in the Era of the Great Resignation

Learn about what has worked - and what hasn’t - to help retain talent at other organizations

Retaining Employees in the Era of the Great Resignation

Effective human capital management practices are key to thriving during the workplace revolution.

Workplace Origami: Making Sense of the Forces Shaping the Workplace in 2021

How the Liberty Mutual team is approaching personalization in the workplace.

How Liberty Mutual Drove Global Efficiency with Drupal as the Foundation for their Intranet

The workplace is changing in ways we couldn’t have anticipated. Here are the top considerations for organizations as they adapt.

Top 10 Challenges For the Workplace of the Future

Learn how leading organizations use EX tools to connect people with the resources they need in the field or on the move.

Making the Employee Experience Empathetic to Frontline Workers

Learn how to build a work environment that enables people to do their best work and creates more satisfied and productive teams.

If Employee Experience Isn’t Your Department’s Top Priority, It Should Be

Learn how Mondelēz International’s unified communications team is improving employee experience with better communication.

Making Teams Work: The New Era in Unified Communications

Learn how to accelerate your business's digital transformation with modern and agile development platforms.

Low-Code — The Enabler that Brings IT & Business Together

How AI improves each stage of the search journey

Moving Beyond Traditional Enterprise Search

How to leverage business process management (BPM) for operational excellence

These Companies Excel at BPM and Process Automation and You Can Too

How to build a new team culture dedicated to the proactive mindset.

Mondelēz: 3 Steps to a Data-Informed, More Proactive IT Department

Learn the three steps companies should take to create a successful hybrid enterprise and enable better productivity.

How to Create a Successful Hybrid Enterprise Using Slack

Join Workgrid’s Rob Ryan and Frank Pathyil to discuss the challenges in building or buying an intranet.

How to Modernize Your Intranet and Avoid the Build or Buy Headache

Get a frontline view on the considerations and technologies organizations are evaluating as they reopen the office.

Let’s Get Ready to Reopen!

In this webinar, we’ll explore real-world use cases that illustrate the transformational benefits of employee-centric IT.

The Race for Digital Transformation: Employee-Centric IT Against the Odds (with Paddy Power Betfair)

Digital workplace expert Sam Marshall leads a live fireside chat exploring the challenges in adapting to a complex world of work.

How AI Can Unify Your Digital Workplace

Hear how leading companies are reimagining their digital transformation projects and identifying new opportunities for growth.

Making the Complex Possible: How to Accelerate Your Digital Transformation

Explore the innovative tools that help make the transition back to hybrid and in-office work seamless.

How to Use Space Reservation Tools to Return to the Office Safely

Explore how to implement a cross-departmental center for employee experience and make the biggest impact.

Liberty Mutual: Building a Center of Excellence for Employee Experience

Hear how Cisco embraced a culture of trust and conscious leadership to power an inclusive workforce.

[CMSWire Webinar] Best Practices for Enabling a Remote and Hybrid Workforce

Join us to explore the future of collaboration and knowledge management in modern organizations.

Web Accessibility and What Brands Need to Know: Q&A With Steve Barnes

About the author

Tags

Featured Research